BLOGGER TEMPLATES AND TWITTER BACKGROUNDS »

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Questionaire




Question 1
Does the designs give the impression that is similar to their supposed use? (does home look like home etc.)
A. Yeah
B. Not at all
C. Somewhat unclear

Question 2
What do you think of the colors?
A. Cool!
B. ....why is it so dull?
C. Pure Ugliness

Question 3
Do the design looks as though they are a set? (similar design)
A. Hell yeah!
B. Dude, they do not even look similar!
C. A little, need more characteristics!

Question 4
What do you think about the icons being using only 2 colors (vector) and three colors (pixel)?

Question 5
And finally, please give your opinions! Any improvement ideas?

21 comments:

Justin Lim said...

1 c 2 a 3 a 4 metal colors. black red. AWESOME!!!!
5 maybe change the color of the devil horns for HOME. i didnt know it was until i saw GALLERY. nice work though

$@nDr@ said...

1.A
2.A
3.C
4.okay i guess...but i find the vector one kinda...monotone?Or maybe that's the intention.
5.not much opinion to give.i pretty much like the pixel ones so that's about it.

Rich Boy said...

1.A
2.B
3.A
4.No real prob with it, but maybe cuz the pic is too small it looks kinda unclear
5.the vector looks too...black? maybe needs more red, pixel is cool

The CJ said...

By Jonas (who dunhave blogger account):

1. A
2. B
3. A...

4. for u.. black n red of course! but d value of red can be higher a bit so can b more eyes catching~

5. d colour gradation can be more contrast, especially for Vector Set icons. Coz is kinda dull n d image doesn't really stand up

Apple Tan said...

1. Yes
2. Yes but maybe can lighten up the gallery's icon, abit too dark. :P
3.Yes
4. simple and it shows that they are a set design.
5. I liked the vector ones! :)

The CJ said...

By Marcus Chen

Does the designs give the impression that is similar to their supposed use? (does home look like home etc.)
A. Yeah

Question 2... See More
What do you think of the colors?
B. ....why is it so dull?

Question 3
Do the design looks as though they are a set? (similar design)
A. Hell yeah!

Question 4
What do you think about the icons being using only 2 colors (vector) and three colors (pixel)?
Looks good to me

Question 5
And finally, please give your opinions! Any improvement ideas?
CD could us some light ,Gallery is a little dark can't see the hand icon in it very well ... that is all

The CJ said...

By Lucas Fong

1.C 2.A 3.A 4. fine tuning might be needed for vector just to enhance it a little. pixel looks awesome in my view.
5. hmm all in all i like it just the touchin up like i mentioned in question 4 is all

Yi Pin said...

1. yeah

2. not sure if its just my display, but the vectors could have a little more contrast, overall they look too dark

3. yes

4. not much to say about that as long as it works. pixels look fine to me, but vectors could be more interesting

5.
i. might want to try red lines in the vector set to show the shapes better and also set the mood for your theme.

ii. might want sharper edges for the pixel music note bar?

iii. good job overall, the designs are consistent and the mood is set clearly according to the theme. I like the vector set, it looks neat and professional. keep it up! =)

Nongkyndong said...

Question 1
(C. Somewhat unclear). All the icons convey the message very well, however, the vector home is not immediately obvious. Maybe try to remove the little portion (sorry, i can't make out what it is) between the hand and the roof. Might make it clearer?


Question 2
(A. Cool!) I think the choice of colour suits the theme of the icons. It is apparently a heavy metal sort of theme (I guess), so the colour is suitable. However, the brown under the pixel home looks a bit off. It doesn't blend well with the overall colour scheme.

Question 3
(A. Hell yeah!) The icons definitely look like they belong in a set. The art style is fairly consistent.

Question 4: Colours?
I think you managed the colours quite well, however, I think the saturation is too low. Depending on the background of the interface in which you might use the icons, it could be hard to make out the details.

Question 5: Comments
The workmanship is very well executed in my opinion, however I feel the shadows are a little bit inconsistent, I had the same problem when I did my icons, XD.

The smaller music vector's shadow is a little too light compared to the rest.

The smaller gallery vector's shadow is too big and dark.

But, I think you did pretty well overall. Hope this helped, XD

~Shaii

Stefie Chin said...

stefie

1: A
2: A, the lighting part nid to enhance to make it more contrast
3: A
4: the color combination is ok... jz the vector part, the value can be more contrast^
5:ya, change the vector red color to a lighter one^

Nix said...

Question 1
Does the designs give the impression that is similar to their supposed use? (does home look like home etc.)

C. Somewhat unclear
Especially the Vector Home.

Question 2
What do you think of the colors?

B. ....why is it so dull?
Since this is a visual communication, u shud try make some really "polished" looking icon. The colour combo is fine with me, but u need to add some highlight and at some point lighten up. The vector Gallery is honestly very dimmed. hehe.

Question 3
Do the design looks as though they are a set? (similar design)
A. Hell yeah!
Raster ones are great.


Question 4
What do you think about the icons being using only 2 colors (vector) and three colors (pixel)?

ok i guess, but like i said, vector needs improvements, colour wise. Raster really OK d.

Question 5
And finally, please give your opinions! Any improvement ideas?
Raster very clear and attractive, dude. Vector tho, the Home, maybe la if u can change instead of the metal sign being so big, why not use it as the u know farm houses with roof-chicken-arrow thing? Just my thoughts la. And colour..U need to make the shadow darker (obvious), midtones u ok d, highlight (obvious)..so tho they are blended, but it is more visually striking. :)

xX Kazukii Xx said...

Question 1
Does the designs give the impression that is similar to their supposed use? (does home look like home etc.)
A. Yeah

Question 2
What do you think of the colors?
B. ....why is it so dull?

Question 3
Do the design looks as though they are a set? (similar design)
A. Hell yeah!

Question 4
What do you think about the icons being using only 2 colors (vector) and three colors (pixel)?
- nicely done very suiting colors.

Question 5
And finally, please give your opinions! Any improvement ideas?
- nicely done. but for your vector "home" it's unique but it doesnt really looks like home to me. on the other hand your pixel"home" again color is alil too bright. others all ok!

The CJ said...

By Trisha Fong (Facebook)

1.A 2.A 3.C 4. I like the contrasting two toned stuff but that's just my opinion 5. I'm not a very good critic so I've got nothing.. its alright i think..

khairina razif said...

1:A

2:B

3:A

4:i like it, the two hard rock color...cool!!!!!!!

5: The color of vector is dull, u have to make the highlight and 3D and make the color brighter... by the way nice work!!!

Benny said...

1.C
2.a
3.c
4. simple and cool....i like it
5. the vector for the gallery i think the color should make it lighter coz i think is abit dark

SAi said...

1. a

2. b

3. a

4. it doesnt make much difference having 2 colours for vector and 3 for pixel.

5. the vector icons, you shoukd use a bit lighter colour. that would help the user to recognize the icons better.

Lucyness said...

1.C
2.A
3.A
4.It suits the theme rock.. so no problem there ;)
5.Its a little too dark, the details are not really visible until looked more than once

Bobby Shin Keng Lam said...

1.a 2.a 3.a 4.dun see any prob there 5.Its cool and all, just pretty dark.. other that that i like the red/black combo, gj bro!

Lau Yen Donny said...

1.A
2.A
3.C
4.good combination
5. No real problem other than the vector ones being too dark, but the pixel ones are awesome!

The CJ said...

By Helena Chin (Facebook)

1.c 2.b 3.a 4.its ok, i guess...hmm 5.im not really good at commenting other peoples work, but if anything the colour of the vector very dark le, maybe if u lighten the colour will look better =)

fazlina said...

Question 1
Does the designs give the impression that is similar to their supposed use? (does home look like home etc.)

C. Somewhat unclear

Question 2
What do you think of the colors?

B. ....why is it so dull? -4 pixel/rascal icons only.

Question 3
Do the design looks as though they are a set? (similar design)

A. Hell yeah!

Question 4
What do you think about the icons being using only 2 colors (vector) and three colors (pixel)?

I like the 2 color combination in the vector n its mixed well n the image is still clear .. but the 3 colors look fade n didn't match well ...

Question 5
And finally, please give your opinions! Any improvement ideas?

The vector design was fine but i think(its from my view) that the house design didnt look like a house.
and for pixel...cuz it really look so pixel like zooming picture closely..so i dislike that icon..but the design was cool..!
I dunt have any ideas but i think u need to try to upgrade new house icon for vector..